In one glittering, star-studded evening, the Baby2Baby Foundation raised more than $20 million, with the likes of Ciara, Kerry Washington, and Cardi B in attendance. It’s a number worth celebrating and one worth sitting with. According to a 2024 report from the Giving Gap, the funding gap facing Black-led nonprofits is roughly $20 million. And for Black leaders in the nonprofit space, the discrepancy is still felt today.
“Philanthropy is in no way exempt from these kinds of inequities, as is health or education or any other social system.” Heather Infantry, CEO of the Giving Gap, shared in an interview with theGrio.
The Giving Gap was founded in 2020, when calls to support Black businesses during the pandemic were joined by calls to support Black-led charities. According to Infantry, the full scope of the disparity is hard to pin down. Much of the data used to measure giving in the U.S. comes from the 990 tax forms nonprofits are required to file, and those forms don’t ask about the race of an organization’s leadership. Still, the research that does exist points in one direction. In a conversation with theGrio, philanthropic leader and nonprofit executive Tish Johnson-Jones pointed to data from the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy showing that less than 1% of traditional philanthropy goes to organizations serving Black communities.
For many Black nonprofit leaders, the gap shows up long before a check is ever written. Infantry explained that Black-led organizations are often held to standards their white counterparts aren’t, from having full-time staff and a minimum budget just to qualify for funding to producing audited financial statements and proof of expertise.
“Nonprofit organizations led by us, on the other hand, will be given things like technical assistance in lieu of dollars because it’s believed that we can’t be good stewards of money,” she said. “And what’s so interesting about the philanthropy sector is that these are folks that are in the business of giving away money. That’s the job.”
Rather than meeting organizations where they are, she said, funders “send them through an obstacle course of paperwork and applications,” adding that many grant guidelines “masquerade as institutional policy when, in a lot of ways, it’s just a way to keep people out.”
And even when the money does come through, it often comes with strings attached. Simone Hardeman-Jones, a philanthropic leader and nonprofit executive, explained that funding for Black-led organizations is most often restricted, meaning it can only be spent on a specific program rather than wherever the organization needs it most.
“The giving gap isn’t just about dollars,” she said. “You jump through all these hoops, you do an application, you apply for a grant, and you get $20,000. It’s like, what am I going to do with $20,000 [when you have to meet payroll and juggle the numerous needs to keep a nonprofit afloat,” Hardeman-Jones said. “You’re constantly fundraising… you never get to get ahead and dream boldly about what you want your impact to be or even get to the point where you can grow, expand, and scale. Because you’re like, ‘I’ve got to look for the next check to meet payroll.’”
Johnson-Jones described the cycle as a “chicken and egg” problem. Funders often want years of data and outside evaluations, which are expensive to produce, before they’ll write bigger checks. Many also look for organizations that have already expanded to new cities.
“We want you to expand, but we don’t want to give you the resources to do that because you haven’t expanded,” she said. “It’s like, I’m just trying to keep my lights on.”
Chelsea VonChaz, founder and executive director of the menstrual equity nonprofit Happy Period, knows that reality firsthand. Nearly 12 years after she started handing out period products on Los Angeles’ Skid Row, she said demand for her organization’s work “isn’t going anywhere,” but the funding to meet it hasn’t kept pace.
“It’s kind of hard for us to talk about or have discussions about scaling when we’re so deep into keeping our operations afloat,” she told theGrio.
The root of this discrepancy lies in layers, from unspoken biases to a lack of visibility and more.
“People are so comfortable in giving the money to the white-led organization that serves Black people instead of giving to the Black-led organization that is serving Black people,” VonChaz shared. “If you don’t call the thing out, they’re gonna say, ‘Oh, it doesn’t even exist.’”
Meanwhile, Infantry calls it what it is: white saviorism, “and it is very much well funded.” But another persistent issue in the philanthropic space is proximity.
“You give to who you know. You give to who you have relationships with,” Johnson-Jones said, explaining the attitudes of many funders in the space. “If I don’t know you, I don’t trust you.”
That mindset transcends race. In Black communities, it often looks like giving only to our churches or alma maters. Hardeman-Jones urges donors to also consider causes they’re passionate about, and since parting with hard-earned money takes trust, she suggests first attending an organization’s events or volunteering to get a hands-on feel for its impact.
For Infantry, watching Black nonprofits receive a flood of donations, then lose that support just as quickly, has her rethinking sustainability. Rather than knocking on the doors of systems designed to push us out, she wonders if it’s time to return to our ancestors’ community fundraising practices: mutual aid funds, sou-sous, rent parties, fish fries. And as Johnson-Jones points out, rent parties never really went away; they just got rebranded as galas with fancier dress codes.
“Black people are still so often seen as the recipients of the charity and not the givers. But Philanthropy is in our DNA,” Hardeman-Jones said. “We were some of the earliest philanthropists before it looked like writing a check to something. It was sou-sous, someone’s daughter needing a place to stay, and so you opened your doors… Really, philanthropy is about love.”
So what can you do this Giving Tuesday? Johnson-Jones suggests starting local and giving collectively. Joining a giving circle, she said, can turn a $100 or $1,000 donation into real impact when it’s pooled with others. Donors can also open a donor-advised fund through a community foundation and ask to be connected with Black-led organizations. And ultimately, no matter the amount you give, as Hardeman-Jones notes, these donations help institutions that will serve Black communities for generations.
Give to our community on Giving Tuesday, on Wednesday, Thursday, and throughout the year, as often as you can, with as much as you can,” Infantry concluded. “It’s an all-of-us project… every day, 365.”